Aliens

Why is that in almost every science fiction work I’ve encountered, alien species are depicted as being monocultural?

Think of any popular sci-fi movie, book or series. If it has aliens in it, then chances are any particular alien species has only one language, has only one worldview/religion, one set of cultural practices, and probably only one style of fashion. Most of the time, individual members of this species all look alike and talk alike as well.

Even worse, sometimes certain alien species are associated with a particular emotion or quality; i.e. Star Trek‘s Klingons are “angry” and “warlike” while Vulcans are “wise” and “logical”. We would never put up with this kind of stereotyping if it were applied to human characters, but for other species, we are willing to suspend our disbelief.

When you consider the breadth of diversity in our own species when it comes to language, culture, worldview and fashion, I think it’s unlikely that other sentient life would tend toward monoculture. Within a single human culture there is more diversity and difference than there is in the entire species of Klingons.

Come to think of it, these aliens usually from planets with only kind of terrain. Think of Star Wars and the “ice world” of Hoth, the “desert planet” of Tatooine, the “forest moon” of Endor, etc. From the (admittedly very little) that we have seen of the cosmos, most planets with only one type of terrain are incapable of supporting life (Venus, Mercury, Mars, etc).

I think this shows a lack of imagination on the part of speculative fiction writers.

Advertisement

3 Comments»

  M G Kizzia wrote @

The assumption may be that for any speciec to reach the level of technology necessary for interstellar exploration, it must have settled most internal differences and come to a cooperative arrangement if not a single government. I would not disagree with that assumption. That does not mean the species is without protests or underground movements or a plethora of subcultures, but they may not be relevant to the story.

  Kaosu wrote @

Hi MG,

Thanks for the comment (my first comment, unless you count “Mr. WordPress” :D ).

You make a good point, but I’m still not convinced that this accounts for lack of alien diversity. Does a single government necessarily mean an end to different cultures across a world? The UN isn’t exactly a world government, but if we assume that it acquired the ability to actually enforce its resolutions it would leave us with a united governing body but a plurality of cultures, languages, religions, etc.

The humans in these space operas normally also have some kind of central Federation or Empire or something, but nevertheless they also still have more diversity than their alien counterparts.

  M G Kizzia wrote @

Perhaps the only way to resolve this is to write the story yourself, but boy, I think that would be hard to do. I imagine it would be like a fish trying to write about life outside the water. We might be able to recognize something as alien to our human experience and way of thinking, but to recognize all the shades and depth and breadth of those aliens, unless they simply mirror humanity, that would be tough.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.